Saturday, February 24, 2024
HomeLaw and orderOf Malawi’s ConCourt overboard mandate…AG Kaphale performed as law demands

Of Malawi’s ConCourt overboard mandate…AG Kaphale performed as law demands

Malawi Attorney General Kaphale

By Nenenji Mlangeni

LILONGWE-(MaraviPost)-Malawi’s Constitutional Court (ConCourt) nullification of May 21, 2019 polls deeply exposed two politics at play which one of is the national politics and the political leaning of the judges who presided over the case.

For instance Judge Heyley Potani is a known staunch Malawi Congress Party (MCP) supporter, and one of the Judges is a cousin with Mary Chilima. How could you expect a fair judgment from this?

The second politics are the politics within the judiciary. Judges contest for positions and have a satiable appetite to rise on the pecking order. The highest court to ascend is the Supreme Court.

Malawi is a country of laws. So, as a lawful nation with three arms of government; Executive (President and cabinet ministers) Legislature (Members of Parliament) and Judiciary (courts, judges), need to be respected.

Therefore, each arm of government there remain a number of laws and legal processes and procedures provided in our Constitution to regulate how we conduct ourselves to resolve our situation.

The most important thing is that we must preserve our constitutional order and ensure that Malawi continues to be stable and peaceful.

The judges in their offensive reading of the judgment showed their bias and prejudgment of the case.

It was rather strange that the judges felt the need to insult a Supreme Court judge, Justice Jane Ansah – calling her incompetent.

It was the same “incompetent” Malawi Electoral Commission (MEC) and Jane Ansah who presided over the Parliamentary elections that saw about 193 MPs put in office.

The judiciary cannot instruct nor prescribe to Parliament on what laws should be passed. Parliamentarians are elected by the voters to make laws — not judges. Parliamentarians do not report to the courts, but the electorate.

There was a complete misrepresentation of the electoral systems by the judges.

Further, the ConCourt went further telling Attorney General Kalekeni Kaphale to stop representing President Peter Mutharika and MEC in future upon snubbing the stay order on the February 3, 2020 verdict.

The panel of the five judges also stressed that its ruling against the involvement of AG Kaphale in the case was not a mere comment.

Judges therefore went way above their “heads” on the role of AG for state’ legal matter.

Malawi currently uses First Past the Post Westminster system. The US, Canada, India, and the many Caribbean and African states still use the system. The First Past the Post is a subset of the majoritarian system.

What’s the role of Attorney General in Malawi?

The President appoints him for a term of five years which may be renewed for further terms of five years.

By virtue of section 98 (1) of the Constitution, the Attorney General is the principal legal adviser to the Government.

In terms of section 98 (1) of the Constitution, the office of Attorney General may either be held by a Cabinet Minister or by a public officer.

In practice, the person appointed as Minister of Justice doubles up as Attorney General.

In that case the office of the Attorney General becomes a political office. The Attorney General is responsible for advising the Government on all legal matters and conducts civil litigation for and on behalf of the Government.

He may be removed from office by the President only on the grounds of incompetence, incapacity or being compromised in the performance of his duties to the extent that he is no longer able to give impartial legal advice.

Even in United States of America (USA) and United Kingdom (UK) shares similar roles of AG as Malawi does

The attorney general holds the power of attorney in representing a government in all legal matters. … The attorney general serves in the Cabinet of the president of the United States. The attorney general is in charge of supervising United States attorneys and marshals in their respective judicial districts.

The attorney general holds the power of attorney in representing a government in all legal matters. The Attorney general is nominated by the president and confirmed by the U.S. Senate.

There is no designated term for the Attorney General; rather the president can remove him or her from the office at any time. Additionally, the attorney general can be impeached and tried by Congress if deemed necessary.

As head of the Department of Justice and chief legal counsel to the president, the duties of the attorney general are obviously important and wide reaching.

The attorney general prosecutes cases that involve the government and gives advice to the president and heads of the executive departments when needed.

While in UK, the attorney general’s main role is to advise the government on any legal repercussions of their actions, either at meetings or in writing.

The key responsibilities of the role include: Overseeing the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) and Serious Fraud Office with the authority to prosecute cases.

The UK Attorney General offers legal advice to the government in England and Wales. Officially known as Her Majesty’s Attorney General for England and Wales, the attorney general works with the subordinate solicitor general as the chief legal adviser of the Crown and its government.

The case of Malawi AG Kaphale

Therefore, during the entire Malawi Presidential Election Case, it was difficult for AG Kaphale to remain in office leaving his backing state legal team lonely in court.

As the case was political in nature, Kaphale was indeed needed to be in court to give legal advice on the how the case was supposed to be preceded.

This is the reason, the public kept of hearing the AG tussling with the petitioners’ legal team in court when the hearing was off-track.

The only crime Kaphale has committed is work along with the team that is deemed to be rigged the polls not necessarily his role and mandate as Attorney General.

Judges therefore again went way above their “heads” to scold AG Kaphale on his legal role of the state’ lead lawyer.

The ConCourt must always respect other arm of government not dictating entire system.

Maravi Post Reporter
Maravi Post Reporter
Op-Ed Columnists, Opinion contributors and one submissions are posted under this Author. In our By-lines we still give Credit to the right Author. However we stand by all reports posted by Maravi Post Reporter.


  1. If the writer should be closer ,I would shake hands with him..
    Our rotten courts eish…
    Where z Malawi going? Politics everywhere,,in churches, NGO’s, judiciary,,,,may God heal this country

  2. Kaphale should not have used the same JUDGES for Injunction relief. Only times Injuction are granted is when the Judge feels your case has Merit on Appeal. I thi Case it is obvious Potani does not think so. Kaphale should have demanded a different Judge not Five Judges

    • Who ever wrote this he or she is a goat. You deny judges while the case is pending. Where were them when the case was started? You bring conflict of interest on appeals level expect overturn based on that? Bunch of BS.

      You show that you don’t know how this works. A party has the right to deny a judge but has no right to choose a judge. Which judge should kaphale choose? Just educating you it is a registrar/ clerk of the court who pick the presiding judges or sometimes chief judge of the court.
      The court was right to kick out AG because the court document shows that he was representing APM not MEC and he argued on APM who is not a alone a public. AG kaphale mess up things himself from the beginning. If he was representing MEC only the court could have no discretion to kick him out.
      You need more legal studies dude

Comments are closed.

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments

James Hastings Chidule on Malawi’ fistula recovery at 86%
WELLINGTON WITMAN MOSELIJAH LUNDUKA on The history of Ngoni Maseko in Malawi
Lisa Frank on Home
azw3 on Home
Define Regtech on Home
Tobias Kunkumbira on Malawi to roll out Typhoid vaccine
arena plus nba standings 2022 to 2023 ph on Home
David on Home
마산출장 on Home
Cristina Thomas on Home
Alicia Alvarado on Home
The History of online Casinos – Agora Poker – hao029 on The History of online Casinos
Five factors that will determine #NigeriaDecides2023 - NEWSCABAL on Leadership Is Difficult Because Governance Is Very Stubborn, By Owei Lakemfa
Asal Usul Texas Holdem Poker – Agora Poker – hao029 on The Origins of Texas Holdem Poker
Malawi has asked Mike Tyson to be its cannabis ambassador - Techio on Malawi lawmaker Chomanika against Mike Tyson’s appointment as Cannabis Brand Ambassador over sex offence
Finley Mbella on Brand Chakwera leaks Part 1
Maria Eduarda Bernardo on The 2021 Guide to Trading Forex Online
Atsogo Kemso, Political Foot Soldier on Why MCP and UTM Alliance Will Fail
Em. Prof. Willem Van Cotthem - Ghent University, Belgium on Malawi army, National bank cover Chilumba barrack with trees
Christopher Murdock on Why dating older woman is dangerous?
Samantha The Hammer on Why dating older woman is dangerous?
Muhindo Isevahani on The Cold War Against TB Joshua
JCON/SCOAN/BKN(888/8885/8808) on The Cold War Against TB Joshua
Keen Observer on Jesse Kabwila, Then and Now
Francesco Sinibaldi on Advertising in 2020 and beyond
VICTORIA NAMENE FILLIPUS on Is TB Joshua not another religious fraudster?