LILONGWE-(MaraviPost)-The Malawi Human Rights Commission (MHRC) has told President Lazarus Chakwera’s Tonse government not to force people to get COVID-19 vaccines citing human rights violation.
The commission has issued the statement following Minister of Health Khumbize Kandodo Chiponda’s announcement last week that civil servants including journalists will go for forced jabs.
Below is the full MALAWI HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSIONSTATEMENT ON MANDATORY COVID-19 VACCINATION
The Malawi Human Rights Commission (the Commission) has noted with concern Government’s announcement, through the Minister of Health, who is also Co-Chair of the Presidential Task Force
on Covid-19, to introduce mandatory vaccination by January, 2022. According to the statement,
this will affect all public servants, frontline workers, and those working in the social sector,
These new measures have direct impact on the enjoyment of human rights. A fundamental
principle within international human rights law is that vaccinations, like any other medical
interventions, must be based on the recipient’s free and informed consent. Compulsory vaccination
is an interference with the human right of bodily integrity, which is a part of the right to private
life enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Ultimately, international law
provides a strong indication that the right not to be subjected to medical treatment is an absolute
right that cannot be limited. This ought to set a very high bar on any attempt to mandatory forms
of medical treatment — including vaccination. Government should consider multiple interests,
that is, individual human rights and collective rights – All protected by human rights law – and
strike a fair balance between them.
In this regard, the Commission is not in support of mandatory Covid-19 vaccination as it violates
fundamental human rights as guaranteed by the Constitution of the Republic of Malawi and other
international human rights instruments, even if the issue of collective or public rights is brought
into the equation. While the Commission has always supported voluntary vaccination, it is of the
view that the public by now should be able to assess the greater benefits for itself in being
vaccinated, and should weigh these benefits against defending their rights.
The Commission therefore advises Government to maintain its current position that Covid-19
vaccination is voluntary and embark on massive civic education and campaigns, aimed at
demystifying the myths of vaccines so that people can make informed decisions regarding the
vaccine. The strategy should aim at making as many people as possible access vaccination services
voluntarily, and not by coercion.
The Commission holds that any attempt to adopt mandatory Covid-19 vaccination (“with
exceptions”) should be the last resort after exhausting all less coercive and non-punitive means.
MALAWI HUMAN RIGHTS COMMIS ION
The Commission is not convinced that all efforts have been exhausted by the State (and other
actors) to educate the people on the need for and workings of the vaccines in an effort to convince
them to voluntarily vaccinate.
The Government should fully satisfy the six (6) World Health Organization (WHO) Ethics and
Covid-19 Working Group preconditions (vaccine safety; efficacy and effectiveness; necessity and
proportionality; sufficient supply; public trust; and ethical processes of decision making) to
necessitate any decision for the introduction of mandatory Covid-19 vaccination). For example,
can the Government prove that it has the capacity to vaccinate every person who needs the vaccine
when a mandate is introduced? Can the Government demonstrate that it has so far put up the best
and comprehensive public education on the Covid-19 vaccines? Can the Government demonstrate
that it has put in place exceptions to the mandate that takes into considerations non-derogable
rights such as freedom of conscience or belief? Can the Government demonstrate that it has done
thorough, transparent consultations and engagement with all relevant stakeholders including
affected parties such as non-vaccinated and vulnerable groups before arriving at introducing a
mandate? Only if the answer to these questions is in the affirmative can the Government consider
introducing mandatory vaccination.
The Commission therefore finds mandatory vaccination not only intrusive and coercive but also a
violation of human rights. This measure can only be considered if voluntary mechanisms have
clearly failed, and which is not the case at the moment. All efforts must be made by Government
and all its partners to propagate the benefits of accessing Covid -19 vaccines for the greater good
of every Malawian.
st December 202